Sports rules get passed down through casual conversation almost as often as they get learned from an actual rulebook, and along the way, small inaccuracies calcify into widely repeated myths. Some of these misconceptions are oversimplifications that were once true and never got updated; others misunderstand the rule from the start. This article walks through several of the most persistent myths across different sports and explains what the actual rule says.

Myth: An NFL Tie Always Goes to Overtime

It's true that American football games can go to overtime when regulation ends tied, but the myth is the word "always." In the NFL's regular season, overtime is played under a modified sudden-death structure, but if the score is still tied after the single overtime period allotted for regular-season games, the game officially ends in a tie rather than continuing indefinitely. This surprises a lot of fans because playoff games work differently: in the postseason, additional overtime periods are played until a winner is determined, since postseason games cannot end in a tie. So the accurate version of the rule is that regular-season games can end tied after one overtime period, while playoff games keep going until there's a winner.

Myth: Offside in Soccer Is About Where You Receive the Ball

This is one of the most common misunderstandings in soccer. Many casual viewers believe a player is offside based on where they are standing when they receive the ball, but that's not what the rule actually measures. Offside position is judged at the moment the ball is played by a teammate, not when it's received. A player can be standing in a position that would be offside, receive a pass, and not be flagged, as long as they were in an onside position at the exact moment their teammate struck the ball. This is also why assistant referees watch the passer's foot contact the ball before checking the receiving player's position, rather than freezing the moment of reception. The distinction matters enormously in practice, since a fast attacker can run from an onside position into what looks like an offside spot by the time the ball arrives, and still be perfectly legal.

Myth: Icing in Hockey Is Called the Instant the Puck Crosses the Line

Icing is often described as an instant, automatic call, but that's not quite accurate under the touch-icing and hybrid-icing variations used in most competitive leagues. Under a touch-icing standard, the puck must actually be touched by a player from the team that didn't ice it before the whistle is blown, meaning a race to the puck can determine whether icing is actually enforced. Many leagues now use hybrid icing, where officials make a judgment call based on which player, attacking or defending, would most likely reach the puck first near the end boards, often determined by who reaches the face-off dots first, rather than waiting for an actual touch. Either way, icing is not simply whistled the moment the puck crosses the goal line; there's a race-and-judgment component that fans who only half-remember the rule frequently miss.

Myth: Any Shuffle of the Feet Is Traveling in Basketball

Traveling is one of the most argued-about calls in basketball, partly because fans often believe any noticeable foot movement without dribbling is automatically a violation. The actual rule centers on the pivot foot and the gather step. A player is allowed to establish a pivot foot once they stop dribbling and then move their other foot, but they cannot lift and move the pivot foot itself without releasing the ball on a pass or shot. Additionally, modern interpretations explicitly allow a "gather" sequence, where a player can take an extra step while gathering the ball before beginning their counted steps toward a pass or shot. This gather-step allowance is frequently misunderstood as "no rules being enforced anymore," when in reality it's a codified part of how steps are counted, not an absence of the traveling rule.

Myth: The Infield Fly Rule Means Any Pop-Up Gets an Automatic Out

The infield fly rule is one of baseball's most misunderstood provisions, largely because its purpose gets lost in translation. It only applies under a specific combination of conditions: there must be fewer than two outs, and there must be runners on first and second base, or on first, second, and third base, since the rule exists specifically to prevent an infielder from intentionally dropping a catchable fly ball to set up an easy double or triple play against runners forced to advance. If a pop-up occurs with a runner only on first base, or with two outs already, the infield fly rule does not apply at all, no matter how routine the catch looks. When the rule is in effect, the umpire declares the batter out immediately once a fair fly ball is judged catchable by an infielder with ordinary effort, but this declaration only happens under those specific base-and-out conditions, not on every infield pop fly.

Myth: A Let Serve Means the Point Is Automatically Replayed Forever

In tennis, a let occurs when a serve touches the net cord but still lands in the correct service box, and the common understanding that the point is simply replayed is correct as far as it goes. The misconception creeps in around how lets interact with fault counts and, in some competitions, the let-serve rule being eliminated entirely. Traditionally, a let serve doesn't count against the server at all, so a server can hit an unlimited number of net-cord lets on a given point without being penalized, and each one simply gets replayed. However, some professional events and tours have experimented with or adopted "no-let" rules, where a serve that clips the net and lands in is simply played as a live ball rather than replayed, removing the let exception altogether. This means the "let is always replayed" assumption isn't universal across every level and event of the sport, even though it remains the traditional and most widely applied version of the rule.

Why These Myths Persist

Most of these misconceptions survive because they describe a simplified version of a rule that's close enough to correct most of the time, which makes the error hard to notice in casual viewing. Offside usually does look like it's about where the ball is received, because attackers and the moment of the pass are often close together in time. Traveling calls often do involve messy footwork, so the pivot-foot technicality gets lost in the visual noise. Understanding the precise mechanics behind each rule doesn't just resolve arguments; it also deepens appreciation for how much split-second judgment officials are applying in real time.

Quick Recap

Want to test what you just learned?

Take the Other Sports quiz →